Which patio dining set fits best with my patio set?

Stevyamda

Hi! I am debating between these two patio dining sets (below is our deck with current sofa set (off white cushions)). Any preference? Both are black aluminum with rattan wicker chairs and have an umbrella hole (where our current umbrella will go). Thanks!

JasmineHart

I see it's been a while since you've posted, but I just wanted to ask if you ended up choosing a dining set. I’ve been in a similar spot trying to match materials and finishes, especially with mixed wicker tones. Sometimes just adding cushions or an outdoor rug can help tie everything together—curious if that worked out for you or if you found another way to blend the pieces.

Jimboscope

I had a similar setup, and mixing textures worked great for me. I found a black metal set with simple lines that didn’t clash with my existing wicker seating. I’d check out a patio furniture sale nearby—sometimes you’ll spot something unexpected that fits the vibe without overthinking it. I got mine during one and ended up loving how it pulled everything together without being too matchy.